Tragedy in Bethpage: Three Young Men Killed After SUV Slams Into Tree and Catches Fire

 

Our New York Car Accident Lawyers Discuss Legal and Investigative Issues Following Mother’s Day Fatal Crash on Long Island

Three lives were tragically cut short in the early hours of Mother’s Day after a 2022 Dodge Durango veered off the road and slammed into a tree near Bethpage State Park in Long Island. The vehicle immediately burst into flames, killing all three 20-year-old occupants inside. Nassau County police confirmed the identities of the victims on Tuesday: Gino Vicale of Seaford, Nicholas Rivera of Glendale, and Vincent Cavaliere of Bethpage.

The crash occurred around 1 a.m. on Stymus Avenue, as the SUV was reportedly heading eastbound. Authorities are still working to determine the cause of the crash, including who was driving at the time and how fast the vehicle was traveling.

As New York car accident lawyers, we know that crashes like this often raise many difficult questions—for the families, for investigators, and for the community.

What Happens When the Driver Is Unknown?

In cases where multiple occupants perish and the identity of the driver is unclear, a detailed accident reconstruction is typically required. Toxicology tests, black box data, eyewitness accounts, and physical evidence from the scene may all play a role in determining:

• Who was operating the vehicle at the time of the crash
• Whether alcohol, speed, or other contributing factors were involved
• Whether any third-party liability (e.g., another driver or vehicle defect) may be relevant

Can the Families of the Victims File a Legal Claim?

When a single-vehicle accident results in multiple fatalities or injuries, the legal analysis becomes complex—particularly if one occupant was driving and others were passengers. In such cases, the families of the passengers may be able to bring a wrongful death claim against the estate of the driver, depending on the facts established during the investigation.

Additionally, legal options may exist if:

• A defective vehicle component (e.g., fuel system, brakes) contributed to the explosion or loss of control
• Road conditions or missing signage played a role
• A third party (such as a bar or establishment) overserved alcohol to a visibly intoxicated driver in violation of New York’s Dram Shop laws

While the investigation continues, it is clear that this tragedy has left families devastated and a community grieving.

Speak With an Experienced Long Island Car Accident Attorney

In the aftermath of a fatal crash, it is critical that the families involved understand their rights and have access to the facts. Our firm represents victims of catastrophic motor vehicle accidents across New York Metro  including Long Island and has the resources to conduct independent investigations and pursue justice on behalf of families.

If you have lost a loved one in a car accident and have questions about your legal options, contact our office at 212-943-1090 for a free, confidential consultation.